논문 상세보기

《論語·述而》“文莫吾猶人也”新考 KCI 등재

A New Investigation of “Wen Mo Wu You Ren Ye(文莫吾猶人也)” in the Analects · Shu Er

李肖雨, 鄭春蘭
  • 언어CHI
  • URLhttps://db.koreascholar.com/Article/Detail/452449
구독 기관 인증 시 무료 이용이 가능합니다. 5,800원
漢字硏究 (한자연구)
경성대학교 한국한자연구소 (Center For The Study of Chinese Charaters in Korea, Kyungsung University)
초록

The exegesis of the chapter on Wen mo wu you ren ye (文莫吾猶人也) (Analects 7.33) has been perennially contentious in classical scholarship. Building upon a thorough review of traditional commentaries, this paper undertakes a further critical re-examination of the interpretations of this chapter from two complementary perspectives—philological glossing and philosophical elucidation. It argues that the view that Mo (莫) is a scribal error for Qi (其) is the most cogent and the corruption most likely arose from miscopying during the transcription of the ancient-script text. The sentence Wen qi wu you ren ye (文其吾猶人也), when subjected to syntactic restructuring, reveals its original form as Wen, wu you ren ye (文,吾猶人也)—a topic-prominent construction. However, since its semantic import in this chapter is not self-sufficient and requires logical cohesion with the following clause to achieve full meaning, the sentence undergoes syntactic restructuring under the constraints of the chapter's overall expression. The restructured syntax forms a concessive-conditional relation with the subsequent clause, thereby highlighting the significance of Gong Xing (躬行).Through Confucius’ self-assessment, this chapter ultimately conveys the idea that mere acquisition of Wen (文) is insufficient without their performative actualization.

키워드
The Analects of ConfuciusUnearthed LiteratureGraphical Corruptiontopicalization structuresyntactic restructuring
목차
目 錄
1.舊注梳理與辨正
2.“文莫”章析論
    2.1 “莫”爲“其”字之誤
    2.2 “文莫<其>”一章的義理闡釋
3.結語


저자
  • 李肖雨(四川大學文學院漢語言文字學專業碩士研究生) | Xiaoyu LI
  • 鄭春蘭(四川大學文學院教授) | Chunlan ZHENG
같은 권호 다른 논문