논문 상세보기

하나의 자유형에 대한 일부집행유예 KCI 등재

Suspension of Execution of a Part of a Imprisonment

  • 언어KOR
  • URLhttps://db.koreascholar.com/Article/Detail/373890
서비스가 종료되어 열람이 제한될 수 있습니다.
刑事判例硏究 (형사판례연구)
한국형사판례연구회 (Korean Association of Criminal Case Studies)
초록

It is not related to construction of Article 62② whether “suspension of execution of a part of a imprisonment” is admitted or not, because a concept of ‘a part’ in Article 62② and a concept of ‘a part’ in suspension of execution of a part of a imprisonment are different. The question of “suspension of execution of a part of a imprisonment” is related to construction of Article 62①.
While article 62① provide requisites for suspension of execution of sentence, Article 62② provide only suspension of execution of a part of sentence in case of concurrent imposing of punishment by article 62①. Therefore, it is difficult to comprehend that article 62② provide another requisites for suspension of execution of sentence as article 62①.
And it is unreasonable to interpret “… the execution of the sentence may be suspended” as “… the execution of the whole of a sentence may be suspended” in article 62①. Because a concept of ‘a part’ in suspension of execution of a part of a sentence and a concept of ‘a part’ in Article 62② are different essentially, and because a concept of ‘the whole’ in suspension of execution of a part of a sentence and a concept of ‘the whole’ in Article 62② are different essentially. And ‘a sentence’ has two meaning: a sentence against a crime and a sentence against several crimes. Therefore, it is unreasonable to interpret that ‘a sentence’ in article 62② and in suspension of execution of a part of a sentence have same meaning.
It is proper that suspension of execution of a part of a imprisonment is solved by not interpretation but legislation, because it is of great no advantage to the accused.

목차
[대상판례] 대법원 2007. 2. 22. 선고, 2006도8555 판결
  [사실관계]
  [판결요지]
 [연 구]
  Ⅰ. 들어가며
  Ⅱ. 형법 제62조 제2항의 해석
  Ⅲ. 형법 제62조 제1항의 해석
  Ⅳ. “하나의 형”의 실질적 내용
  Ⅴ. 결 론
 
저자
  • 이천현(한국형사정책연구원) | Lee Cheon-Hyun (Korean Institute of Criminology)