논문 상세보기

Jurisdiction Ratione Temporis in Successive International Investment Agreements: What Can Chinese Investors Learn from the Ping An Case? KCI 등재 SCOPUS

  • 언어ENG
  • URLhttps://db.koreascholar.com/Article/Detail/388500
구독 기관 인증 시 무료 이용이 가능합니다. 7,000원
이준국제법연구원 (YIJUN Institute of International Law)
초록

China’s foreign investment has been growing rapidly since 1990s. In this course, the first investor-state arbitration case raised by a mainland Chinese investor, Ping An v. Belgium, drew attention to an important issue – jurisdiction ratione temporis in successive international investment agreements. It is controversial in theory and practice as to whether the basic principle of non-retroactivity should apply to the dispute settlement clause in a successive agreement. This is especially true when tribunals are interpreting different kinds of jurisdictional clauses. This paper will take the Ping An Case as an opportunity to thoroughly analyze the issue of temporal jurisdiction in successive international investment agreements. Based on such analysis, this paper will also do reflection on relevant articles in China’s existing investment agreements, providing suggestions to China regarding the issue of jurisdiction ratione temporis, in an effort to make arbitration more certain and avoid possible dismissal, as occurred in the Ping An Case.

목차
I. Introduction
 II. The Ping An Case and the Jurisdiction Ratione Temporis
    A. Overview
    B. The Tribunal’s Decision
 III. Theoretical Foundation of Jurisdiction Ratione Temporis
    A. The Principle of Non-Retroactivity
    B. Methods of Treaty Interpretation
 IV. Jurisdiction Ratione Temporis in Practice
    A. Main Categories of Provisions on Jurisdiction Ratione Temporis in Existing IIAs
    B. Jurisdiction Ratione Temporis in Existing Investor-State Arbitration Cases
    C. Reflection on the Ping An Case
 V. What can China Learn from the Ping An Case on Jurisdiciton Ratione Temporis?
 VI. Conclusion
 References
저자
  • Chunlei Zhao(Law at Maastricht University, China Bar, CUPL, CUPL / Hamburg)