Typology of stability risk factors in fishing vessel capsizing: a verdict-based case analysis
Catch, gear, and deck loads on a fishing vessel may change in quantity and distribution, and lines, gear, and anchor cables may transmit external forces, so stability at departure or ship-handling immediately before an accident may not fully explain capsizing. This study aimed to extract stability-related risk factors from verdict narratives and to compare their configurations across cases. We purposively selected thirteen Korea Maritime Safety Tribunal (KMST) verdicts with relatively clear descriptions of stability deterioration. Keeping the legal cause findings unchanged, we used directed qualitative content analysis to code accident development along two routes: reduction in restoring capacity (Route I) and line- and gear-mediated external force (Route II). Route I comprised degraded loading condition (A), moving weight (B), and flooding, drainage failure, and free-surface effect (C); Route II comprised line- and gear-mediated external force (D). We treated ship-handling and environmental conditions as background rather than separate types. Legal cause findings and risk types did not correspond one to one. Two accidents attributed to imprudent hauling were coded C and D, and B and D, respectively; D also appeared under different legal cause findings. In the selected cases the two routes did not always coexist, and cases coded on both routes did not have higher combined numbers of deaths and missing persons than single-route cases. The classification does not replace KMST causal determinations, but it can differentiate inspection priorities among accidents sharing a legal cause. For types A, B, and C, crews can directly check loading height and position, securing, and drainage before and after fishing operations and address them through onboard inspection and training. For type D, crews can inspect equipment condition and work procedures, but cannot judge load magnitude or its effect on stability by eye alone. Line tension over time, the direction and point of application of the force, and GM, GZ, and heel angle by loading condition, therefore, need to be confirmed by measurement and calculation. This study organizes the accident development described in verdicts into risk types and presents an analytical framework for type-specific inspection and follow-up measurement.