논문 상세보기

Prompt Writing as Metapragmatic Feedback-Seeking Practice in Generative AI-Mediated L2 Revision KCI 등재

Claudia Sangmi Yun, Hyekyung Yu
  • 언어ENG
  • URLhttps://db.koreascholar.com/Article/Detail/452925
구독 기관 인증 시 무료 이용이 가능합니다. 6,400원
사회언어학 (The Sociolinguistic Journal of Korea)
한국사회언어학회 (The Sociolinguistic Society of Korea)
초록

As generative AI becomes increasingly integrated into L2 writing instruction, a central pedagogical challenge concerns not only students’ access to AI-generated feedback but also how they formulate requests for such feedback. This study examines the metapragmatic feedback-seeking practices evident in prompts written by 131 first-year Korean university EFL students during a four-hour classroom revision task using ChatGPT (GPT-3.5). The primary dataset comprised 655 student-generated prompts, with five prompts from each participant addressing content, coherence, organization, word choice, and sentence structure. A data-driven thematic analysis first identified three mutually exclusive pragmatic gap categories: ambiguous prompts (n = 436, 66.6%), overly broad prompts (n = 163, 24.9%), and criteria-lacking prompts (n = 56, 8.5%). Cohen’s kappa (κ = .85) was calculated for this three-category classification. A second interpretive analysis then examined how the omissions characteristic of these categories left different aspects of evaluative specification and contextual inference unresolved for the generative AI system. This distribution is interpreted analytically, not as evidence of students’ intentions. Based on the recurring omissions, this study derives the Goal–Target–Criteria (GTC) heuristic post hoc. It also offers the Reflective Question Loop (RQL) as an untested pedagogical proposal for future classroom implementation, rather than as an intervention evaluated in this study. The study contributes to sociolinguistic accounts of human-AI interaction by showing how prompt wording configures evaluative authority, inferential burden, and participant roles during L2 revision.

키워드
prompt literacymetapragmatic feedback-seeking practicegenerative AI-mediated L2 revisionevaluative authorityfeedback literacy
목차
Abstract
1. INTRODUCTION
2. REVIEW OF LITERATURE
    2.1. AI Tools in Language Learning: Applications andConsiderations
    2.2. Prompt Writing as AI-Mediated Feedback Seeking in L2Writing
    2.3. L2 Revision and Teacher-Guided Prompt Writing
3. METHODOLOGY
    3.1. Participants
    3.2. Instruments
    3.3. Data Collection
    3.4. Data Analysis
4. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
    4.1. RQ1: Recurring Pragmatic Gaps in Student-GeneratedPrompts
    4.2. RQ2: Distribution of Evaluative Specification andInferential Burden
    4.3. Pedagogical Implications: Heuristic Post Hoc GTC and theProposed RQL
5. CONCLUSION
REFERENCES
저자
  • Claudia Sangmi Yun(Visiting Professor, Department of English, College of Humanities and Social Science, Kangwon National University; 346 Jungang-ro, Samcheock-si, Kangwon-do, 25913, South Korea)
  • Hyekyung Yu(Instructor, Department of English Language and Literature, College of Humanities, Jeju National University; 102 Jejudaehak-ro, Jeju-si, Jeju-do, 63243, South Korea) Corresponding author