In Korea, two types of spent nuclear fuels (SNFs) are generated, pressurized light water reactor type (PWR) and pressurized heavy water reactor type (PHWR; CANDU), that differ greatly in size, decay heat, and radioactive characteristics. Technology development for the disposal of SNFs has mainly focused on PWR SNFs that are large in size and have extremely high decay heat and radioactivity. However, CANDU SNFs should be considered differently from PWR SNFs in deep geological disposal systems because their characteristics significantly differ from those of PWR SNFs in terms of their dimensions, number of SNF bundles, and handling systems in nuclear power plant sites. In this paper, after reviewing the status of the CANDU SNF disposal concept by Canada and Korea, concepts related to the direct geological disposal of CANDU SNFs were described, and two concepts were proposed based on the results of the development. The engineered barrier systems developed using these two concepts were comparatively analyzed in terms of disposal safety, disposal efficiency, and technical maturity. Based on the results of the comparative analyses, a vertical-type emplacement disposal concept was determined as a reference concept for the deep geological disposal of CANDU SNFs.

It is expected that around 576,000 bundles of CANDU spent nuclear fuels (SNF) will be generated from the four CANDU reactors located at the Wolsong site. The authors designed and proposed a reference disposal concept based on the KBS-3 type and KURT geological data in 2022. In addition, we have reviewed the literatures and selected four alternative disposal methods to develop the higherefficiency disposal concept than the reference concept since 2021. As known well, the most important safety functions of the geological disposal are containment and isolation, and the secondary function is retardation. A disposal canister covers the former, and buffer may do the latter. In this study, we design the engineered barrier systems for the four alternative concepts: (1) mined deep borehole matrix, (2) sub-seabed disposal, (3) deep borehole disposal, and (4) multi-level dispoal. Assuming total 10,000 tU of CANDU SNF, four different kinds of unit disposal module consisting of disposal canisters and compacted bentonite buffers are designed based on the technique currently available. Two alternative concepts, sub-seabed disposal and multi-level disposal, share the same unit module design with the reference concept in 2022. For all the alternative concepts, we assume that the density of the compacted buffer is 1.6 g/cm3. For the mined deep borehole matrix disposal, we introduce a disposal canister slightly modified from the Canadian NWMO canister with a capacity of 48 bundles. The thickness of a copper layer is changed to be 10 mm considering the long-term corrosion resistance. The buffer thickness around a disposal canister is 20 cm, and the diameter of a borehole is 100 cm. Two different kinds of buffer blocks are proposed for the easy handling of them. For the deep borehole disposal, a SiC-stainless steel canister is designed, and 63 bundles of CANDU SNF is emplaced in the canister. We expect that the SiC ceramic canister shows very excellent corrosion resistance and has a high thermal conductivity under the geological conditions. The deep borehole will be plugged with four layered sealing materials consisting of granite blocks, compacted bentonite, SiC ceramic, and concrete plugs.

It is expected that around 576,000 bundles of CANDU spent nuclear fuels (SNF) will be generated from the four CANDU reactors located at the Wolsong site, according to the 2nd National Plan for the management of High-Level radioactive Waste (HLW). The CANDU SNFs are currently stored at the dry storage facilities at the Wolsong site. The authors proposed KRS+ geological disposal system consisting of two different concepts, Swedish KBS-3V type and Canadian NWMO type, for the final management of CANDU SNF. Both the concepts were designed based on the geological data obtained from the KURT (KAERI Underground Research Tunnel). The NWMO type is an in-room horizontal placement method. In this study, we try to determine the reference concept among the two proposed concepts at 500 meters below the ground surface. Assuming 10,000 tU of CANDU SNF and the KURT site, we design two engineered barrier systems, that is disposal canisters and buffers. The copper disposal canister is designed with a copper thickness of 10 mm based on a cold spray coating technique for both the disposal concepts. The domestic Ca-bentonite is used for the compact bentonite buffer with dry density of 1.6 g/cm3. Two concepts are compared in terms of safety, economics of the engineered barriers, and environment-friendliness. Because the same amounts of CANDU SNF are disposed of at the same depth, the differences in the disposal area are neglected. For the comparison in terms of safety, the corrosion lifetimes of the disposal canisters of two disposal systems are quantitatively calculated, and the capacities for retarding radionuclide releases of the compacted bentonite buffers are assessed. A computer tool developed by the authors is used in order to assess the lifetime of a disposal canister. In this study, the case that corrosion of a copper canister by sulfide from groundwater through intact buffer is analyzed. The sulfide concentration in groundwater is assumed to be 3 ppm. The most important safety function of buffer is to retard the radionuclide release. Twelve long-lived radionuclides are selected to compare the capacities for retarding the radionuclide transport through the buffer using an analytical solution. The retention time by an engineered barrier consisting of a disposal canister and a buffer is compared with twenty times the half-life of each radionuclide for both the disposal systems. The selected reference concept will be compared with the alternative geological concepts through a further study.

The research for the safe management of high-level waste in Korea has been conducted by the Korea Atomic Energy Research Institute since 1997, and the results have formed the basis of the national basic plan for the high-level waste management and the revised national basic plan. In the future, it is evolving and developing R&D focusing on securing technologies for demonstration of the disposal technologies and R&D to develop disposal concepts that increase safety and improve efficiency. Efficient management of heat generated from high-level radioactive waste, including spent nuclear fuel, is an important factor in establishing the disposal concepts because it must be in harmony with key factors such as repository layout, waste disposal container specifications, and design and operation for the barriers of the disposal system. For safe and complete isolation of highlevel radioactive waste in the deep geology, the disposal systems that meet the thermal requirements for the disposal system design have been developed by harmonizing the thermal characteristics of engineered and natural barriers in Korea. These disposal systems were based on low burn-up spent nuclear fuel characteristics generated in the early stages of nuclear power generation, and next, based on the high-level wastes from recycling process of the high burn-up spent nuclear fuels, and were the direct disposal systems for the high burn-up spent nuclear fuels. So, it is necessary to track and analyze the change process in the decay heat characteristics of the high-level waste to be disposed of in order to improve the disposal concept, which enhances the safety of disposal and the utilization of the national land. Therefore, in this paper, the process of change in decay heat of reference spent nuclear fuels for disposal applied to the disposal concepts from the initial stage of development of high-level waste disposal technology to the present in Korea is analyzed.

Around 40 years ago, in the mid-1980s, Swedish government approved the KBS-3 method for the direct disposal of spent nuclear fuels (SNF) in Sweden. Since then, this method has become a reference for many countries including Korea, Republic of. The main ideas of the KBS-3 method are to locate SNF at 500 m below the ground surface using a copper disposal canister and a bentonite buffer. In 2016, our government announced the National Plan (NP 2016) regarding the final management of high-level waste (HLW) in Korea. In 2019, new committee were organized to review the NP 2016, and they submitted the final recommendations to the government in 2021. Finally, the government announced the 2nd National Plan in December, 2021. So far, KAERI has developed the technologies related to the final management of SNF in two directions. One follows ‘direct disposal’ based on the KBS-3 concept, and the other ‘recycling’ based on ‘pyroprocessing-and-SFR’ (PYRO-SFR). Even though Posiva and SKB obtained the construction permits with the KBS-3 method in Finland and Sweden, respectively, there are still several technical obstacles to applying directly to our situations. Some examples are as follows: high burnup, huge amounts of SNF, and high geothermal gradient in Korean peninsula. In this work, we try to illustrate some limits of the KBS-3 method. Within our country, currently, the most probable disposal option is the KBS-3 type geological disposal, but no one knows what the best option will be in 20 or 30 years if those kinds of drawbacks are considered. That is, we compare the effects of the drawbacks using our geological data and characteristics of spent fuels. Last year, we reviewed alternative disposal concepts focusing on the direct disposal of SNF and compared the pros and cons of them in order to enhance the disposal efficiency. We selected four candidate concepts. They were multi-level disposal, deep borehole disposal, sub-seabed disposal and mined deep borehole matrix. As mentioned before, KAERI has developed a pyroprocessing technology based on the SFR to reuse fissile radionuclides in SNF. Even though we can consume some fissile nuclides such as 239Pu and 241Pu using PYRO-SFR cycle, there still remain many long-lived radionuclides such as 129I and 135Cs waiting for the final disposal. The authors review and propose several concepts for the future final management of the long-lived radionuclides.

우리나라에서는 현재 23기의 원자력발전소를 운영 중에 있으며, 이들 원자력발전소로부터 발생하는 사용후핵연료를 처분 대상으로 기준 심지층 처분시스템을 개발한 바 있다. 현재 이 기준 심지층 처분시스템은 초기농축도 4.5wt%, 방출연소도 55 GWd/MtU의 40 년 냉각된 사용후핵연료를 기준으로 하고 있다. 본 논문에서는 처분효율 및 경제성 향상 방안의 일환으로 서 사용후핵연료의 종류 및 연소도 특성 등 발생특성을 검토하였다. 그리고 기준 사용후핵연료에 비하여 길이가 짧고 연소 도가 비교적 낮은 사용후핵연료에 대한 처분용기 개념을 도출하고 열해석을 수행하여 처분시스템 개념을 제시하였다. 또한, 이 처분시스템 개념과 기준 사용후핵연료 처분시스템 개념을 처분밀도, 처분면적 등의 처분효율 및 구리와 벤토나이트 소요 량 등 경제성 관점에서 비교 분석한 결과 약 20% 이상 향상을 보이는 것을 확인하였다. 본 분석결과는 사용후핵연료 관리정 책 수립 및 실제 처분시스템 설계에 활용될 수 있을 것으로 사료된다.

사용후핵연료 또는 고준위폐기물의 안전한 처분을 위하여 지난 수십 년 동안 많은 나라들이 다양한 처분대안을 연구하여 왔다. 본 논문에서는 심지층처분기술에 있어서 사용후핵연료를 직접 처분하는 방안으로서 처분효율 향상을 위한 다양한 방 안 중의 하나로 고려할 수 있는 PWR 사용후핵연료 집합체를 해체하여 연료봉을 밀집한 경우에 대한 처분 효율을 분석하였 다. 이를 위하여, 우선 사용후핵연료 연료봉 밀집개념과 관련 처분용기 및 심지층처분 개념을 설정하였다. 이 개념에 근거하 여 심지층 처분시스템의 공학적방벽 설계에 있어서 가장 중요한 요건인 완충재의 온도 제한요건을 만족시키는지 여부를 확 인하기 위하여 각 처분개념 별로 열해석을 수행하였다. 그리고, 처분공 간격, 처분터널 간격 및 처분용기 열발산 면적에 따 른 열해석 결과를 바탕으로, 단위처분면적 관점에서의 처분효율을 비교/분석하고 평가하였다. 또한, 사용후핵연료봉을 밀 집시킨 경우에 있어서 냉각기간에 따른 처분개념을 분석하였다. 분석결과에 따르면 사용후핵연료봉을 밀집하여 심지층처 분하는 경우 처분효율 측면에서 불리한 것으로 판단되었다. 다만, 사용후핵연료의 냉각기간을 70년 이상으로 장기화 할 경 우 처분효율은 향상될 것으로 예상되지만, 사용후핵연료의 내구성 및 장기저장에 따른 조건 등 추가적인 분석이 필요하다.

우리나라에서 발생하는 사용후핵연료를 CANDU형과 PWR형 2종류로 구분한다. PWR형 사용후핵연료의 경우 적절한 공정을 거쳐 원료물질로 다시 사용할 수 있는 물질을 많이 포함하고 있어 재활용 공정을 고려할 수 있다. CANDU형 사용후핵연료는 천연 우라늄을 원료물질로 사용하고 있어 재활용 가능성이 거의 없으므로 직접 처분을 고려하고 있다. 본 논문에서는 PWR형과 CANDU형 사용후핵연료 모두를 직접 처분하는 개념 으로 개발한 한국형 사용후핵연료 처분시스템을 바탕으로 CANDU형 사용후핵연료 처분 시스템을 향상시키 는 방안을 도출하고자 하였다. 이를 위하여, 현재 원자력발전소에서 사용하고 있는 사용후핵연료 60 다발 (Bundle) 용량의 저장바스켓을 포장·활용하는 방안으로 처분용기 개념을 개선하였다. 이들 개선한 처분용 기를 기반으로 하여 사용후핵연료의 심지층 처분시스템에 있어서 주요한 제한요건인 폐기물로부터 발생된 열로 인하여 완충재의 온도가 100 ℃를 넘지 않도록 하는 요건을 만족시키면서 효율을 향상시킨 처분시스템 개념을 제시하였다. 제시한 처분 시스템 개념들은 장기저장 및 회수성이 용이한 방안을 도입한 개념과 개선 한 처분용기를 1개 처분공에 2단으로 처분하는 것으로서 이들 개념을 기존 한국형 처분시스템과 효율성 측면 에서 비교?분석하였다. 본 연구를 통하여 얻은 CANDU 사용후핵연료 처분개념은 단위면적당 열효율, Udensity, 처분면적, 굴착량, 완충재 및 폐쇄 물질량을 30∼40 % 까지 효율을 향상시킬 수 있었다.