Once decommissioning begins, it is expected that large amount of radioactive wastes will be produced in a short period of time. The expected amount of radioactive wastes from Kori unit 1 NPP are approximately 80,000 drums (base on 200 L). By minimizing the amount of radioactive wastes generated through decontamination and reduction, KHNP has set the final target for the amount of radioactive wastes to be delivered to the disposal site at approximately 14,500 drums. Here, plasma torch melting technology is an essential technology for radioactive wastes treatment during nuclear power plants decommissioning and operation, because of its large volume reduction effects and the diversity of disposable wastes. KEPCO KPS was able to secure experience in operating Plasma Torch Melter (PTM) by conducting a research service for ‘development of plasma torch melting system advancement technology’ at KHNP-CRI. This study will compare kilo and Mega-Watt class PTM, largely categorized into facility configurations, operating parameters, and waste treatment. Based on this study, it would be desirable to operate PTM with approximate capacity according to the frequency and amount of waste production, and suggest volume for a kilo and Mega-watt class plasma torch in the melting furnace respectively. This plays to its strengths for both a kilo and Mega-watt class PTM.
A disposal of radioactive wastes is one of the urgent issues in worldwide. Considering upcoming plans for decommissioning of nuclear power plants, this problem is unavoidable and should be discussed very thoughtfully before long. There are variety of methods to deal with radioactive wastes, including Incineration process, conventional gasification process and plasma gasification process and so on. Among them, plasma gasification process is in the limelight due to its ecofriendly features and very large volume reduction effects. So, lots of countries like Japan, Taiwan, Russia, Bulgaria are already utilizing commercial plasma melting facilities and researching their own characteristics & disposal abilities and so on. Within the scope of this paper, I would like to introduce other countries current status of plasma melting facilities, and reach the conclusion on the directions to go for realistic radioactive wastes treatment.
Plasma torch melting technology has been considered as a promising technology for treating or reducing the radioactive waste generated by nuclear power plants. In 2006, IAEA announced that the technology is able to treated regardless of the type of target wastes. Because of the advantage, many countries have been funding, researching and developing the treatment technology. In this study, oversea plasma torch melting facilities for radioactive wastes treatment are reviewed. Also, plasma torch melting facility developed by KHNP CRI is briefly introduced.
Republic of Korea is preparing to decommission Kori Unit 1 and Wolsong Unit 1. Decommissioning of a nuclear power plant proceeds in the following stages: shutdown, transition period, decontamination, cutting, waste treatment, and site restoration. When nuclear power plant is decommissioned, It is expected that approximately 80,000 drums of radioactive waste will be generated per nuclear power plant. Therefore, various technologies are being researched and developed to reduce this to approximately 14,500 drums. Technologies for waste volume reduction are largely mechanical and electrical/thermal methods. Representative examples of mechanical volume reduction technologies include super compactors and electrical/thermal volume reduction technologies include induction and plasma torch furnaces. Both technologies are effective reduction technologies, but the reduction ratio varies depending on the type or condition of waste before treatment. For example, as a result of testing waste reduction using a super compactor at NUKEM in Germany, the reduction ratio was found to be between 1.3 and 7 depending on the type or condition of waste such as chips, ash, scrap metal, sand, etc. And according to IAEA-TECDOC-1527, when reducing the volume of metals, aluminum, lead, copper, brass, etc. using induction melting, the waste volume reduction ratio is 5 to 20. In this paper, referring to these results, a melting test was conducted using a previously developed plasma torch with an output of more than 100 kW. And volume reduction characteristics of this plasma torch was considered depending on waste type or condition.
Normally, non-metallic wastes, such as sands, concrete and asbestos are regarded as electrically non-conductive materials. However, when the temperatures are increased up to the melting point, their electrical conductivities can be greatly improved, flowing arc current. Accordingly, these nonmetallic wastes can be efficiently treated by heating them up to the electrically conducting temperatures by using a non-transferred type plasma torch, and then, melting them completely with arc currents in transferred mode of plasma torch. For this purpose, we propose a convertible plasma torch consisting of three cylindrical electrodes (rear electrode, front electrode and exit nozzle). Compared with conventional plasma torch with two cylindrical electrodes (rear electrode and front electrode), the proposed plasma torch can provide more stable plasma jet in high powered and non-transferred mode due to the presence of exit nozzle, resulting in rapid heating of the non-conductive materials.
Nowadays, transferred type arc plasma torches have been widely present in industrial applications, in particular, using melting pool of electrically conducting materials such as arc furnace, welding and volume reduction of radioactive wastes. In these applications, the melting pools are normally employed as an anode, thus, heat flux distributions on anode melting pool need to be characterized for optimum design of melting pool system. For this purpose, we revisited the one-dimensional model of the anode boundary layer of arcs and solved governing equations numerically by using Runge-Kutta method. In addition, the direct melting process of non-combustible wastes in the crucibles were discussed with the calculation results.
In this work, we report test results for direct melting of non-combustible wastes by using a 100 kW class transferred type plasma torch. For this purpose, non-combustible wastes consisting of metals and sands were prepared, weighed and melted by a transferred arc in a ceramic crucible with inner diameter of 150 mm. Test results reveal that 75wt% M6 iron bolts mixed with 25wt% sands were completely melted down within 140 seconds at the plasma power level of 83.8 kW, producing melting speed of 100 kg/hr and volume reduction rate of 62.8%. In addition, for simulated wastes consisting of 77.3wt% metal chips and 22.7wt% sands, the volume reduction rate high than 88% was achieved at 50 kW plasma power. These results indicate that non-combustible wastes can be treated efficiently when directly melting them by using transferred type plasma torch.
Air conditioning facilities in nuclear power plants use pre-filters, HEPA filters, activated carbon filters, and bag filters to remove radionuclides and other harmful substances in the atmosphere. Spent filters generate more than 100 drums per year per a nuclear power plant and are stored in temporary radioactive waste storage. Plasma torch melting technology is a method that can dramatically reduce volume by burning and melting combustible, non-flammable, and mixed wastes using plasma jet heat sources of 1,600°C or higher and arc Joule heat using electric energy, which is clean energy. KHNP CRI & KPS are developing and improving waste treatment technology using MW-class plasma torch melting facilities to stably treat and reduce the volume of radioactive waste. This study aims to develop an operation process to reduce the volume of bag filter waste generated from the air conditioning system of nuclear power plants using plasma torch melting technology, and to stably treat and dispose of it. It is expected to secure stability and reduce treatment costs of regularly generated filter waste treatment, and contribute to the export of radioactive waste treatment technology by upgrading plasma torch melting technology in the future.
A disposal of radioactive wastes is one of the critical issues in our society. Considering upcoming plans for dismantling of nuclear power plants, this problem is inevitable and should be discussed very carefully. There are variety of methods to handle with radioactive wastes, including Incineration, conventional gasification and plasma gasification. Among them, plasma gasification process is in the limelight due to its eco-friendly & stable operation, and large volume reduction effects. However, a fatal disadvantage is that it consumes more electric power than other methods, this leaves us a question of whether this process is indeed economical. Within the scope of this paper, I would like to introduce 4 cases which plasma facilities were evaluated economically in worldwide, and reach the conclusion on the economic feasibility of plasma process.
Currently, KHNP-CRI has developed 100 kW plasma torch melting facility to reduce the amount of radioactive waste in nuclear power plant. Plasma torch melting technology uses electric arc phenomena like lightning to melt the target material at a high temperature of about 1,600°C. The technology is applicable to treatment for various types of waste such as combustible, non-combustible and mixed wastes. The volume reduction ratio by the technology is respectively expected to be about 1/60 of combustible wastes and about 1/5 for non-combustible wastes. It is important to discharge the melt without problems in the melting technology. In general, molten slag has properties such as high viscosity and quick solidification. Because of the properties, when discharging into slag container, the final product is accumulated like a mountain. To improve this problem, there is three suggestions; 1) rotation of the slag container, 2) vibration of the slag container, and 3) heating of the slag container.
By developing plasma torch melting technology in 1996, our company has developed the first generation 150 kW (’96~’02), the second generation 500 kW (’08~’12), and the third generation MW plasma torch melting facility (’14~’18), and completed facility upgrading (’20~’23). The MW plasma torch melting facility is equipped with CCTV to monitor waste input, melting, torch integrity, and melt discharge. The lens is installed inside a metal housing made of stainless steel to prevent damage caused by external impacts and high temperatures, and supplies nitrogen to prevent cooling and lens contamination. As a result of the demonstration test, as the temperature inside the melting furnace increased after starting the plasma torch, the resolution decreased along with noise in the CCTV, and facility monitoring was difficult due to high temperatures and foreign substances (fume). Based on the test results, CCTV was changed to a non-insertion type that was not directly exposed to high temperatures, and a filter (quartz) was additionally applied to monitor the melt smoothly. As a result of applying the newly manufactured CCTV to the demonstration test, smooth monitoring ability was confirmed even at normal operating temperature (above 1,500°C). Through this facility improvement, the operation convenience of the plasma torch melting facility has been secured, and it is expected that it will be able to operate stably during long-term continuous operation in the future.
Plasma melting technology is a high-temperature flame of about 1,600°C or higher generated using electrical arc phenomena such as lightning, and radioactive waste generated during the operation and dismantling of nuclear power plants is not classified according to physical characteristics. It is a technology that can meet waste disposal requirements through treatment and reduction. Plasma torch melting technology was used for volume reduction and stable treatment of HVAC filters generated from nuclear power plants HVAC (Heating Ventilation and Air Conditioning). filter was treated by placing 1 to 3 EA in a drum and injecting it into a plasma melting furnace at 1,500°C, and the facility was operated without abnormal stop. A total of 132.5 kg of filter was treated, and the high-temperature melt was normally discharged four times. It was confirmed that the plasma torch melting facility operates stably at 500 LPM of nitrogen and 370-450 A of current during filter treatment. Through this study, the possibility of plasma treatment of filters generated at nuclear power plants has been confirmed, and it is expected that stable disposal will be possible in the future.
Plasma torch melting has been considered as a promising treatment technology for radioactive waste generated by nuclear power plants. The IAEA reported in 2006, the plasma melting technology could be treated regardless of the type of radioactive wastes such as combustible, non-combustible and liquid. Also, the technology has the advantage of being an eco-friendly technology. It emits less harmful gases such as NOx, SOx, HCl and CO because it does not use fossil fuels. In KHNP CRI, the plasma torch melting system was developed as the new radioactive waste treatment technology. In this study, to evaluate the long-term integrity of the new facility, a demonstration test with concrete as a simulant was carried out for about 3 days. For the 3 days, the evaluation was conducted in view of abnormal shutdown, soundness of waste feeding device, electrode consumption, and so on.
In KHNP CRI, the PTMs (plasma torch melting system) was developed as a treatment technology of a wide variety of radioactive wastes generated by nuclear power plants. The facility is made of melting zone, thermal decomposition zone, melt discharge zone, waste feeding device, MMI, and offgas treatment system. In this study, demonstration test was conducted using NaOH solution as liquid waste to evaluation the applicability of the PTM system. For demonstration test of NaOH solution treatment, the plasma melting zone is sufficiently pre-heated by the plasma torch for 5 hours. The temperature inside the plasma melting zone is about 1,600°C. The NaOH solution as simulant was put into the thermal decomposition zone by the spray feeding device with the throughput of maximum 30 liter/hour. During the test, the power of plasma torch is about 100 kW on the transferred mode. The 160 liters of liquid waste was treated for 500 minutes. After the demonstration test, the final product in the form of salt was remained in the melting zone, and the disposal of the final product are still under consideration.
We developed a 100 kW Class Transferred Type Plasma Torch applicable for melting of noncombustible metal wastes. By employing reverse polarity discharge structures for hollow electrode plasma torch, a transferred type arc plasma was generated stably with long arc length higher than 10 cm at the arc currents of ~400 A and gas (N2) flow rate of ~50 lpm. High arc currents and high arc voltages caused by the increased arc length could input high power level of ~100 kW to the noncombustible metal wastes, enabling quick melting. In addition, relatively long arc length and low gas flow rates can help reduce the deposition of melted materials on the exit surface of the torch. Thanks to these features, the developed plasma torch is expected to be suitable for small-scaled and portable melting system.
Untreated waste is temporarily stored on the site of the nuclear power plant. In some nuclear power plants, saturation period of temporary storage waste is less than 10 years away. As untreated waste continues to be generated in nuclear power plants, it could also affect management of operations. Accordingly, CRI is developing the 3.5 generation plasma torch melting facility for waste treatment. The 3.5th generation plasma torch melting facility consists of melter, plasma torch, waste supply device, exhaust gas treatment facility, power supply, etc. Melter is composed of melting chamber for melting control and pyrolysis chamber for waste pretreatment, and dam-type discharge device is adopted to overflow the melt. Plasma torch is hollow type with reversed discharge, has a rating of megawatt class, and has two gas supply lines. It can be used in transfer mode, non-transfer mode and mixed mode. There are three types of device for waste supply. The first is a drum pusher for injecting 200 L drums, the second is a screw-type waste supply and hopper for injecting solid waste, and the third is a nozzle-type waste supply device for injecting liquid waste. Exhaust gas treatment facility was equipped with post combustion chamber, off-gas cooler, high-temperature filter, HEPA filter, reheater, scrubber, ID fan and etc. Power supply of plasma torch operation is designed with a capacity of 1.5 megawatt (Maximum) and consists of channels A and B. Transfer mode, non-transfer mode and mixing mode of plasma torch may be selected through the control of PLC. This paper introduces the composition and function of the 3.5th generation plasma torch melting facility of CRI. In order to solve the problems arising through the operation of the 3rd generation plasma torch melting facility, an optimization plan is applied.
The liquid radioactive waste system of nuclear power plants treats radioactive contaminated wastes generated during the Anticipated Operational Occurrence (AOO) and normal operation using filters, ion exchange resins, centrifuges, etc. When the contaminated waste liquid is transferred to an ion exchanger filled with cation exchange resin and anion exchange resin, nuclides such as Co and Cs are removed and purified. The lifespan and replacement time of the ion exchange resin are determined by performing a performance test on the sample collected from the rear end of the ion exchanger, and waste ion exchange resin is periodically generated in nuclear power plants. In the general industry, most waste resins at the end of their lifespan are incinerated in accordance with related laws, but waste resins generated from nuclear power plants are disposed of by clearance or stored in a HIC (High Integrity Container). Plasma torch melting technology can reduce the volume of waste by using high-temperature heat (about 1,600 degrees) generated from the torch due to an electric arc phenomenon such as lightning, and secure stability suitable for disposal. Plasma torch melting technology will be used to check thermal decomposition, melting, exhaust gas characteristics, and volume reduction at high temperatures, and to ensure disposal safety. Through this research, it is expected that the stable treatment and disposal of waste resins generated from nuclear power plants will be possible.
In KHNP CRI, the 100 kW PTM (plasma torch melting) system was designed for the treatment and disposal technology of various radioactive wastes including the metal, concrete, liquid waste and insulator. The facility consists of melting chamber, thermal decomposition chamber, waste feeding system and off-gas treatment system. In this study, to evaluate the applicability of the PTM system, demonstration test was conducted using the radiation hazmat suit as combustible waste. The plasma melting chamber is pre-heated by 2nd combustion device and plasma torch for 5 hours. The temperature inside the plasma melting chamber is approximately 1,600°C. The combustible waste was put into the melting chamber by the pusher feeding device with the throughput of maximum 50 kg/hour. During the test, the power of plasma torch is 60–96 kW on the transferred mod. It was evaluated in terms of long-term integrity of PTM system on operation according to the waste throughput ratio.
Plasma melting technology has been considered as promising technology for treatment of radioactive wastes. According to the IAEA TECDOC-1527 report (2006), the technology has an advantage that it can treat regardless of waste types which is both combustible and non-combustible wastes. In particular, it is expected that a large amount of concrete, a representative non-combustible wastes, will be generated during the operation and dismantling of nuclear power plants. In order to treat the concrete waste in plasma torch melting system, various factors could be considered like the slag of electric conductivity, viscosity and melting temperature. Above all, as a critical factor, the viscosity of the melt is very important to easily discharge the melt. The viscosity of slag (SiO2-CaO-Al2O3 system) can be lowered by adding a basic oxide such as CaO, Na2O, MgO and MnO. The basic oxides are donors of oxygen ions. These oxides are called notwork breakers, because they destroy the network of SiO2 by reacting with it. In this study, the slag composition of the concrete waste was developed to apply the plasma torch melting. Also, demonstration test was performed with the developed slag composition and 100 kW plasma torch melting system.